1/5. Willard, why do you ask questions that were answered at links I just gave you—that you refused to read? I linked to a 7-part tweetstorm about the discredited Shakun/Marcott/Pages2K/Hagelaars "wheelchair" graph, which goes back 22K years. It completely erased D-O event #1, every last trace of it.

You never click in the links I give you, do you, Willard? If you had, you'd have seen the next tweet was: https://twitter.com/ncdave4life/status/1698163293653758289… Your ridiculous graph also preposterously shows the middle of the Dark Ages Cold Period as slightly WARMER than the middle of the Medieval Warm Period, despite overwhelming historical evidence that the opposite was true.

Dave, your figure has D-O events recorded in the Greenland ice sheet (which has good temporal resolution) - and they are largely before 18,000 BP You accused PAGES2K of erasing these events Do have a citation for PAGES2K work going back before 18,000 BP??