Thread Reader
Gabriel Epstein

Gabriel Epstein
@GabrielEpsteinX

Tweet

Buried under the politicking and drawing of red lines about coalition partners after Israel's indecisive election: 920 Arab-Israelis have been killed in crime-related violence since 2023, whether in interpersonal incidents, feuds between clans, or part of major criminal organizational wars. 76.9% feel personally insecure, largely due to the wave of homicides and other attacks, and 80% worry that they or their family will be directly harmed by the violence. In September, the police reported that over 600 grenades had already been thrown across Israel in 2026, largely in criminal incidents, and that they had seized 882 more. In other words: four years of paralyzing violence across the Arab-Israeli community that has allowed criminal organizations to control the streets and left innocent citizens afraid to go out at night or battered by extortion and threats. 🧵

Any next government in Israel will have to reverse this breakdown of law and order, which beyond being a profound governance and security failure is likely to spread from criminal to terrorist attacks. Weapons stolen from IDF bases or flowing in from Jordan and Egypt go to terrorist cells or Gaza just as easily as to organized crime syndicates. Moreover, Israel's criminal underground sees great fusion between Arab and Jewish criminals -- the repeated attacks on the Japanika chain, owned by a Jewish tycoon reportedly affiliated with one of two feuding Arab criminal networks, is only the most recent and visible proof.
A state's first obligation is to protect its citizens, which requires not just a strong military to ward off external threats, but law and order and the maintenance of an internal monopoly on violence. Here, the ongoing failure of the state cries out for correction, and does so as loudly whether the government is a minority or unity and right-wing or centrist. The personal security of Israelis and the maintenance of state power over organized crime and the rule of law are non-partisan issues.
There is the potential to use an already-necessary change in policy to enhance integrationist trends among Israeli Arabs. Ra'am angled for this by including Yoav Segalovitz, a Jewish former deputy internal security minister with a good reputation among the Arab Israeli public for his efforts to fight crime in their sector, as the #2 representative on its list. Bringing Segalovitz into a cabinet position would be both good practically (his model of direct engagement with local leaders and coordinated police work had begun to reduce crime in 2021-2022) and politically, demonstrating to Arab Israelis that their needs are taken seriously. Rather than simply attacking rejectionist elements in the Joint List, whose positions are far beyond the pale for any mainstream Israeli party, there is the opportunity to uplift a different path forward for Arab Israelis by enacting no-regrets policies.
For both Israel and Arab Israelis' benefit, the organized crime networks in the Arab Israeli sector need to be defeated and there needs to be greater investment in Arab communities. Citizenship is, in every successful country and certainly in democracies, a mix of rights and obligations--what the state protects from and allows of its citizens and what the citizens contribute to the state. One of Israel's greatest long-term challenges is that large parts of its citizenry are not sufficiently tied to the state by sentiment or obligation: namely, the Haredi and Arab communities.
Asking for greater obligation from citizens is unlikely to succeed if it precedes protection of their rights, not just the formal ones (which Arab Israelis have long possessed) but in practical matters: the right to walk the streets safely at night, to not be extorted or intimidated by violent gangs, to be treated fairly and protected by the police, and more.
Include Ra'am in the next government or don't, cooperate conditionally with Joint List in the next Knesset or not--there are many important considerations affecting these decisions. But there is no excuse for failing to contain the mass crime wave plaguing Arab Israeli society. The next government, whatever its composition, must do so for the good of all Israelis. They should not miss the chance to bring one of Israel's tribes (to borrow from Rivlin's 2015 speech) closer in the process.
Gabriel Epstein

Gabriel Epstein

@GabrielEpsteinX
Senior Policy Associate @IsraelPolicy4m. Former Research Assistant @WashInstitute. Graduate @SAISHopkins.
Follow on 𝕏
Missing some tweets in this thread? Or failed to load images or videos? You can try to .